Skip to main content
Search IntMath
Close

IntMath forum | Applications of Integration

Difference between disc method, washer method and shell meth [Solved!]

My question

good morning mam, your interactive mathematics is very useful to me for clarify my doubt .Thank you

I have a small doubt:
what is the difference between DISC METHOD ,WASHER METHOD AND SHELL METHOD?

Relevant page

4. Volume of Solid of Revolution by Integration

What I've done so far

Tried to find it on IntMath, but couldnt

X

good morning mam, your interactive mathematics is  very useful to me for clarify my doubt .Thank you

I have a small doubt: 
what is the difference between DISC METHOD ,WASHER METHOD AND SHELL METHOD?
Relevant page

<a href="/applications-integration/4-volume-solid-revolution.php">4. Volume of Solid of Revolution by Integration</a>

What I've done so far

Tried to find it on IntMath, but couldnt

Re: Difference between disc method, washer method and shell meth

Hi Shaikshavali

The disc method for finding a volume of a solid of revolution is what we use if we rotate a single curve around the x- (or y-) axis. If we do that and take slices perpendicular to the axis, we will produce a series of discs (like my watermelon example on this page:)

4. Volume of Solid of Revolution by Integration

If we rotate an area between 2 curves, and then take slices, we won't have a discs, instead we'll have washers (like the ones given in the pictures at the top of the page above).

The Shell method approaches it from quite a different viewpoint. This time we end up with a set of hollow cylinders (something like a water pipe).

You need to use different integration formulas for disks, washers and shells methods.

See this page for explanation and examples of disk and washer methods:

Volume of Solid of Revolution (Disk and Washer Methods)

And see this page for examples of Shell Method:

Shell Method: Volume of Solid of Revolution

X

Hi Shaikshavali

The disc method for finding a volume of a solid of revolution is what we use if we rotate a single curve around the x- (or y-) axis. If we do that and take slices perpendicular to the axis, we will produce a series of discs (like my watermelon example on this page:)

<a href="/applications-integration/4-volume-solid-revolution.php">4. Volume of Solid of Revolution by Integration</a>

If we rotate an area between 2 curves, and then take slices, we won't have a discs, instead we'll have washers (like the ones given in the pictures at the top of the page above).

The Shell method approaches it from quite a different viewpoint. This time we end up with a set of hollow cylinders (something like a water pipe). 

You need to use different integration formulas for disks, washers and shells methods.

See this page for explanation and examples of disk and washer methods:

<a href="//www.intmath.com/applications-integration/4-volume-solid-revolution.php">Volume of Solid of Revolution (Disk and Washer Methods)</a>

And see this page for examples of Shell Method: 

<a href="http://www.intmath.com/applications-integration/shell-method-volume-solid-revolution.php">Shell Method: Volume of Solid of Revolution</a>

Re: Difference between disc method, washer method and shell meth

When we rotate a curve around the x (or y) axis, we can find its volume using the disc method, which works for any solid formed by revolution. If we make perpendicular cuts to the axis, it produces a series of discs, akin to those depicted in my watermelon example.

X

When we rotate a curve around the x (or y) axis, we can find its volume using the disc method, which works for any solid formed by revolution. If we make perpendicular cuts to the axis, it produces a series of discs, akin to those depicted in my watermelon example.

Reply

You need to be logged in to reply.

Related Applications of Integration questions

  • Re: Catenary Equation [Pending...]
    Nevermind! I ended up being able to solve it
  • Shell Method [Solved!]
    URL:Shell Method | Brilliant Math & Science Wiki Under the section, "When to use the shell...
  • Applications of Integrations #11 [Solved!]
    I haven't had calculus in many years but I like to work problems every now...
  • Finding volume using shells [Solved!]
    Exercise 2: The area between the curve y = 1/x, the y-axis and the lines y...
  • How to transform the differential equation? [Solved!]
    Dear friends, I met a problem. I don't know how to transform the equation (13) into...

Applications of Integration lessons on IntMath

top

Tips, tricks, lessons, and tutoring to help reduce test anxiety and move to the top of the class.